Dear, sweet, tenacious, powerful, funny, smart, beautiful daughter,
I’ve avoided writing this because I fear the myriad emotions that will accompany it. I worry that I am unable to bear the weight of countless unnameable BIG FEELINGS. However, this is not the example I want to be, so here I am writing even though I am scared.
I wasn’t sure I wanted to have kids. I saw how hard it was on my parents, and I never wanted that for me. Nor did I want to fail at motherhood. I never wanted to expose my faults to an impressionable young human, thereby creating one more screwed up kid in this world. I didn’t want to be unsure about being able to make ends meet when someone else was dependent on me. I didn’t want to change diapers and clean up perpetual snot. I didn’t want to give up sleeping in and spontaneous backpacking trips to far away countries.
Then I met your dad. I tried not to meet him because he already had a kid (your brother) and that was terrifying. But I couldn’t stop myself, and once we met, we rarely left each other’s side. Because of this, I saw how devoted, involved, and loving your dad was with your brother. I began to question all my assumptions of parenthood. Maybe it’s not so bad? Maybe I could hack it? Your dad wanted you in his life very badly and he wanted me to be your mom…and so we made you.
I was scared the entire time you were growing inside me. I was worried I would hurt you, poison you, lose you. I fretted that you would be born with an extra challenge of a major birth defect, or worse, a fatal disease. I was certain that I couldn’t handle being the parent of a child with any needs beyond the standard. I didn’t trust myself to love you enough. It wasn’t all stress and wringing of hands, however. There were countless joyful, peaceful moments. The first time I felt you wiggle (for sure), the first time I saw you, black and white and blurry on the technician’s screen, the first time I heard your allegro heartbeat, I cried happily. I rubbed my expanding belly and talked to you. I showed you off to friends and family.
We were determined to introduce you to the outside world as gently and naturally as possible. No doctors or fluorescent lights, no interventions, no unnecessary poking, prodding, injections or cutting. Just you , me, and your dad, with our kind and competent midwife standing by. This is what I wanted to give you. I believed (and still do) that a natural, (almost) unassisted birth was one of the greatest gifts I, in my meager capacity, could offer.
We found out you were footling breech somewhere in our third trimester. The doctors in our area have all forgotten how to welcome breech babies into the world. In turn, midwives are forbidden to guide a woman through a breech birth. We tried acupuncture, moxibustion, yoga, music, prayers (a desperate ploy for your agnostic mom), and finally, as a last resort, a painful external version. You remained breech, for reasons I only suspect (but in my gut, I know). We were faced with the choice of transferring to a hospital in another city with a team of doctors and nurses we didn’t know and trying to birth you, or sticking with the people we knew, and cutting you out. I panicked, and I “chose” a c-section because I didn’t trust my body or you. For this, I’m infinitely sorry.
This was only the beginning of a very difficult existence earthside, but that’s a story for another time. Despite every hurdle and obstacle, I began to love you beyond all reason. Through the debilitating post partum depression, I loved you. Through three years of interrupted sleep, I loved you. I have never taken anything more seriously than your fragile life in my hands. I couldn’t give you the gift of a natural birth, but I can offer you the best of me. Sometimes, you see the worst of me too, but your very being makes me fight it.
In three years, you have been my teacher. Sure, I’ve taught you how to count to ten, and eat with utensils, which are all fine for blending in and cohabitating with your fellow western cultured humans, but you have bestowed upon me wisdom that I could not possibly possess without your existence. My compassion and patience grow each day, along with my empathy for other humans. My need to control all things is slowly evaporating. The elusive ability to live in the moment, as tired as that cliché may be, is within my reach. I understand what pure, joyful, unrestrained love really means, and how it feels. This, and infinitely more, I owe to you. Thank you.
You are spirited and headstrong, which will serve you well in this world, especially as a girl. You know what you want, what you don’t want, and how to ask for it. I promise to nurture this as well as I can. You are smart, inquisitive, affectionate, and perceptive. You have more energy than I’ve ever had. You are fearless. I vow to protect and nourish these qualities with all my might. The world will try to take them away from you, but my greatest hope for you is that you are resilient and believe in yourself. Trust in oneself is a rare and powerful tool. I hope to teach you to always honour it. This is the greatest gift I can think to give, on this birthday, and always.
As you begin your fourth year, I celebrate my teacher, my daughter.







Pingback: Around the Size of a Poppy Seed | A Clown On Fire
Sara,
That video still makes me cry………
Love you,
Eric
ME TOO. Every. Damn. Time.
How positively sweet and candid. :) I love it. Good for you Sara. :)
Lovely words, Dani. xo
Oh gosh. This is so beautiful, Sara. Poppy is so blessed to have parents like you and Eric and you both are blessed with a daughter like her. I still absolutely love your “staring” picture with her and the one Eric has on his blog is so priceless as well. I’m sending her a big birthday hug. She is so adorable! Just look at those eyes when she eats the toilet paper :)
Happy Birthday, Poppy!!!! *throws cupcakes*
Cupcakes are in order! I will make a batch for her party in two weeks. Tonight, it’s gluten-free brownies.
We are blessed…that’s the right word. I’m so happy I got to meet her. xo
Oh oh do show a picture of the cupcakes and the brownies :) I baked gluten-free brownies for my cousin a while back. I need to try out more recipes for her when I have the chance! Have a lovely, lovely day. xoxo
Whoops. Brownies didn’t last long enough to appear in a photo. But my secret is gluten-free brownie mix from a bag. And love. The same thing will happen with the cupcakes. THE SUSPENSE!
Ohh no worries as it is a good thing that it vanished so quickly! Love makes it all better!! I used a recipe as I couldn’t find a brownie mix here, so bought special flour. The look on her face was priceless! I am curious about the cupcakes!!!! hehe :)
Way to get a sista mama bawling…I’m still hormonal from the latest bundle haha Poignant and beautiful just like it’s author and thank you for sharing such a very personal part of yourself. I believe, more than ever, that we are kindred mama spirits. Thank you for always being so open and honest and humble about this roller coaster we call parenting. On the days I feel like I’ve absolutely lost my mind, you remind me to laugh, to slow down and best of all to toss all the to-dos and just make chaos with my crazy, free loving, willful as all hell toddler and we all have a better day for it. So bring on the fun and the mess and the loud demanding voices of our insightful kids and celebrate Poppy’s day in true Poppy fashion :)
I cannot believe that I remind YOU about anything parent related. You seem so calm…at least calm enough to have another one. That takes some gonads, lady.
The madness of parenting is much easier to endure when we know there’s others just like us. Thanks for this thoughtful and emotional comment, Sarah.
:) well calm some of the time haha and the 2nd one is a breeze compared to my first little tyrant but I love him! I love them both…one for being the free spirit and strong willed creature he is and the other, bless his heart, for being the happiest, most laid back baby on the planet xo and you’re absolutely right, first time around, those early months I felt so alone in feeling inadequate and struggling with what is always played up as being “natural parental instinct”. I’ve since learned that all us moms have our strengths and weaknesses and to accept that I may never have a martha stewart house with a home made glorious meal on a clean table at 5:30pm every night but I am still a damn good mama and my kids are fantastic irregardless :) and so are you lady! You have a fantastic and glorious kid and step kid and I always love hearing about the adventures of your clan :)
Looking forward to seeing you again, Sarah. xo
What a lovely tribute to your beautiful daughter. It made me cry. (That’s a good cry.) Happy birthday to your little angel. Bonne anniversaire, petite jeune fille.
Glad I could pass the crying around…I’ll be sure to tell Poppy she is loved from afar. Thank you.
This was so sweet! Loved the video.
Poppy is very lucky to have parents like you and Eric. Sure, you may not have done everything according to plan, but she always looks so damn happy and well-adjusted in all of her photos. That’s a parent’s job, and you have done it well.
Happy, well, in photos, yes, and I think, in general. Well adjusted? Better than me I hope but screwed up enough to be funny.
I hope you can forgive yourself for having a c-section. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that. My brothers and I were all born c-section and so were all of my children. The safety of the child is paramount, and that’s ultimately what matters. For what it’s worth, I think you made a wise decision.
I can feel your love for your daughter in your post and that is magical. It seems your fears wear unfounded, and that you are indeed a wonderful mother. Poppy is lucky to have you and you her.
Happy birthday, Poppy!!
I will eventually recover from the c-section. In the meantime, I’m really trying to be a good mum, because that’s what is in my power, and in my control. Otherwise, the rest is up to her and the world. Thanks TD.
I have no doubt that you’re a great mum. I can tell just by reading your beautufil words.
Amazing letter, Sara. She sounds like a very special little girl. Both you and Eric seem to be very loving parents. Happy Birthday to Poppy :)
Love we got. Lots of it. Bills paid in full, not so much, but you’ve got to choose your battles, no?
Thanks NM, I’ll pass on the wishes to the squirt.
Beautifully written Sara …. Poppy will treasure these words … begin a “Treasures File” for her and place this in it …Thank you for sharing with us. Love to you and to Poppy as you journey on together in love.
I have a little shoe box I call “the Poppy box” and this will get added. I wrote with the intention that maybe, someday, she’ll read it. The last three years went by so quickly, I barely remember them. I want to remember this. love you, Grrrr…you have taught me a lot of what I know
Sweet fucking hell. I’m still gasping for air from crying after writing my own post today, and now I come over here and need another whole box of tissues. This is one of the most exquisitely touching and moving and honest things I’ve ever read. I’m bawling again. Fuck you.
OH YEAH!!! Well I’m going to go an cry ALL OVER YOUR BLOG. So there.
I may not be a blogging star, but I can be honest here, and that counts for a lot. Thanks for being the supportive loving friend you are, Weebz.
You may not have been able to give her a natural birth, but you’ve given her a natural life. That’s where it counts.
Happy three years on the planet, Poppy! Thank you lucky stars every day that you have two parents who adore you.
Adored she is, and that counts for a lot. I know you get it. xo
Sara, between you and Eric I have now cried TWICE today. I’ve used up my quota for the year. Thanks. :-P Beautiful post. xo
We team up to wreak emotional havoc on the world. Our job is done here. xo
Oh, Sara, this is so beautiful! Poppy is lucky to have you as a mama! The video brought it back to me how amazing it is to hear the heartbeat for the first time. I think being a parent is the toughest thing there is. You captured it all perfectly here, and it was rewarding to read it. Thanks. Happy Birthday to little Poppy!!
It’s weird and incredible to have two hearts on your person at one time… and there is little that’s more primal and assuring than the sound of a heart beat.
Parenting is very hard, but it’s the least I can do for the kiddo. Much love to you and yours, TBF
Sara,
You are a courageous, strong, and increasingly resilient momma. Poppy is blessed by you as much as you are blessed by her.
Happy Birthday Poppy!
Blessings,
Kina
Some days, I think I’m really getting the hang of it. Others….not so much. But always forward.
xo
What a beautiful tribute to your lovely daughter. How lucky she is to have you and Eric as parents, and how lucky you are to have her.
Our patchwork family is a thing of beauty, well worn and well loved as a quilt.
Seems you are in my head. This is every reason why I didn’t want to have children and also every reason why we are trying to now. Love, love, love it! And when I’m on a computer that doesn’t have Youtube blocked, I will watch the video.
How can anyone block youtube? There’s very educational stuff on there. Fascists. I really believe that those who are most fearful of parenthood are often those who make great parents because they understand the weighty responsibility of it all…or we’re neurotic. Either way, family fun.
Sara -
I’m at a loss for words – which you know is an infrequent problem.
All I can struggle to say is that as I read through your lovely paean to Poppy, I realized that despite everything I may have done wrong in my life, I must have done something incredibly right to have fathered a woman so powerful, genuine and loving.
Even if the rest of my life is a dud, I will know that you, your brother, and now Poppy, are the finest legacy a man could hope to leave.
Happy Birthday to the Birthday Girl, and love all around!
Dad.
Grandpapa bear,
It’s true you passed along some pretty good stuff…more than just a full head of luxurious hair. I’m happy you liked this, because you are a writer for whom I hold the utmost respect. Oh, and you’re my dad, so that’s pretty good too.
Love you,
Sarp
Dearest Sara, while it is true that we choose to become parents, in my experience it is also true that our children choose us as parents. You are your daughter’s mother for her reasons, not yours. Continue to trust that she knows what she wants and how to get it! Happy birthday to all of you! xoxoM
I’m thrilled I’m the one that gets to be her mom, for whatever reasons. She’s a cool little person, and I feel excited that she chose me.
xo
And it sounds like she’s been a very able teacher! Relax, Sara, and enjoy being your little Light beam’s mom! xoxoM
I think maybe Poppy was waiting feet first because she wanted to come out running! She’s a lucky, lucky girl to have such a creative and caring Maman.
That girl was determined to do things her own way from the moment of conception, I’m sure. She hasn’t stopped running!
Thanks, HZ (did I mention I googled Happy Zinny and it made my day?)
It did?? If you found the YouTube channel, I can’t take credit. All I have is a tiny blog!
I was referring to the happy looking flower, but now I feel I should find the youtube…
Or the blog…? My welcome mat is always out and I have fresh poutine. Well, tater tots, anyway!
A beautiful letter that should be given to any woman who even vaguely questions her ability to be a mom. It’ll weed out (hopefully) those who really shouldn’t be moms and give special love to those who might have the same confusion about motherhood that you had. I wish you had been around when I was young and fertile;-)
I really agree that not all humans should be parents. I think we all have different talents and limitations…
Parenting, at least the first time around, is utter confusion. I suppose if I had 5 or 6 more, I’d start getting the hang of it.
Your words are kind. xo
5 or 6 more? Does Le Clown know about this? Or even–especially–Eric?
NOT HAPPENING.
I’m happy to stay in the amateur level of competition.
Wow. *sobbing* So beautiful!
*hands over a tissue*
Here, I have plenty. I also have half a granola bar, a soother, a pair of tiny underpants, and fruit flavoured chapstick if you need it. MOM PURSE.
Lovely post Sara.
Happy birthday to your little girl!
xx
Leo,
Get your ass back to my blog. Thank you.
Le Clown
I’ve been really sick, I saw Jesus and he sent me back.
I’m on my way, gotta read your letter too, I’ve been reading you on facebook but believe, I was too sick to even open my eyes.
Thought it was a goner, I’m mute now, but at least I can read and write (well sorta)
Leo,
You don’t have to justify yourself to me. You’re a friend. Just get your ass back to my blog, and all will be well.
And I do hope you are feeling better. You have a restaurant to run.
Le Clown
Sir, yes, sir!
what the hell’s going on here!!??
Thanks DS,
Glad you’ve recovered enough to type. All is lost, otherwise.
You rock, Sara. I bet Poppy thinks so, too.
X
So far, she likes me. I imagine it will be a different story in 10 years or so. xo
So beautifully spoken!
From the heart often is, or so I hear. Thanks QC
Beautiful!
Happy B-Day Poppy!
Thanks SSG!
One gorgeous baby and one amazing love letter.
I think babies are cute as some kind of survival mechanism to make sure everybody is nice to them.
I think she’s pretty and of course I like hearing it from other people who aren’t obligated to love her. Thanks DM
This is one of the loveliest posts I’ve read in a long time, Sara. I don’t have any children but I often wish my mother had had internet and a blog when I was born and growing as then I’d have had her thoughts from day one. Alas, no such thing in the 1950s.
Poppy is a lovely child. You’re a lovely mum.
It’s a lot easier to keep track with the instant nature of all our technology today. I’ll be glad for it because there’s no way I’m together enough to keep an analogue scrapbook. Of course, if there wasn’t internet, I’d probably have more time…hmmm…
Anyway, all this to say, thank you. xo
You’re welcome.
Really lovely, sweet, and moving post, Sara. Your pictures are wonderful, and that is the best staring contest ever! I was quickly able to read Eric’s post this morning. You two are awesome. Happy Birthday to you daughter!
Thank you, MC! The three (sometimes four) of us make a good team, I think.
Just beautiful! You little love is going to be so happy when she reads this!
And don’t be sad or sorry about having a C-section…sometimes it’s what has to happen. Just like not being able to breast feed – really, it’s the love you have that makes the difference.
Here’s something interesting my friend said during her birthing class. She was not interested in natural childbirth and felt that others judged her wrongly. So she stood up in class and said “look – why is it necessary for me to experience the pain of natural childbirth? It’s like shoving a watermelon through a straw. So tell me, if you were going to have your appendix removed, would you forgo the anesthesia because you felt the need to experience that pain naturally?” – everyone was stunned. She got up, looked around, sneered at judgy-jugertons and went to the bathroom.
That story, whilst tangential, never ceases to make me laugh.
HAPPY BIRTHDAY to your beautiful child ~
It’s true there’s SO MUCH JUDGEMENT around motherhood, before, during and after every stage.
I often got judgement from the other side…raised eyebrows when I told people I how I wanted to birth, breastfeed, cloth diapers, you name it. Like that’s what an expecting, first time mother needs.
Poppy had a great birthday, and the love keeps coming her way. I think she’s enjoying it. Thanks, Rutabaga
*Sniffle*
Sara, that was beautiful.
You are a wonderful mother.
Happy Birthday Poppy! You are one lucky little girl.
HA HA I MADE YOU CRY. I feel like I’ve unlocked some kind of high level game achievement or something.
You’re a great friend. Thank you.
Just beautiful! This gave me goosebumps! Poppy is lucky to have a spectacular family. I only wish all parents could be this candid and honest with themselves and their children.
Thank you
Families are complicated, huh? I’m sure I’ll screw her up in a whole different way…
Thank you for the reassurance, though. Always good to hear (see?).
Yes. Just… yes. Thanks for making me remember. -hugs-
Meeks, I do what I can. xo
;)
I just read an equally sweet and loving post on another blog… I think I just figured something out!!!
The weird pieces are falling into place?
Yes, it’s true, Le Clown and I ARE THE SAME PERSON. Oh wait…not quite. We’re just married.
Oh! I thought he was your daughter! I am a super detective me!
Some days….
Sarah,
You are wonderful. Once again, happy birthday to Poppy and all my good thoughts to you!
Big hug,
mmkng
I’ll be sure to shower her with all the internet abled affection!
Miles was on my lap as I read your letter to Poppy; when he saw the pic of ‘staring contest’ he started laughing. So I pointed at the pic and said “that is poppy, and that is sara.” Then I asked if he could say Poppy, and he shook his head no. Oh well. You’re a wonderful spirit Sara, Poppy is a lucky girl!!
Yay for making babies laugh. Hard to find a sweeter sound.
Seems we have a couple of lucky kids, since Miles gets to hang with you. Thanks, Jenni
Beautifully written (as always). You’re all lucky to have each other, to be the amazing family unit that you are. And my prayers will be said for you all as long as I remember you and read you. Xx
Yours is a generous an loving gesture.
I am determined to make the world a better place via my kids. Thank you.
Sara,
Really beautiful post and tribute to your lovely daughter. From what I know of you and Eric, you win the parents/family of the year award. Poppy will be so touched when you share this with her later in life. What you’ve done here is made me realize how lucky I am to have children (and grandchildren). Thank you so much for sharing.
Red
Well, we have mountains of dirty laundry and dishes, and rely a little too heavily on cereal, but love we have in spades.
I’m happy that you have generations of love on your end. For some reason, I feel that you do a pretty good job yourself.
Thank YOU.
Thanks Sara,
Dishes and laundry; who cares?
And cereal is good!
Good luck today!
John
lovely and your staring contest is just about as beautiful as it gets— both of you.
Thanks, UBS. She won, by the way. She always does.
That was so tender, honest, eloquent and beautiful. I absolutely love the Lomas Robillards, but you already know this.
xoxo
Tracy
Your love is better than smoked meat, Tracy.
You are missed.
Oh MAN! I came from Le Clown all teary eyed to your letter, I’ll have to go have a cupcake myself now to calm down. SUCH lovely words, lucky Poppy. And Happy Happy Birthday.
Cupcakes make most things better.
Poppy has a couple of mushy parents. She’ll hate it in a few years, no doubt, but hey, could be worse!
Thanks, WF
Gorgeous post, Sara. I relate to this entirely. And I can’t tell you how to feel, but I too was a c-section baby and I don’t know if you know this, but I’m pretty kick ass. In fact, I think I’m like at least 5% kick assier than most people because of it. I’ll update you with the results of my experiment later in the week.
I love science.
I eagerly await your abstract in the next Medical Journal of Science and Other Hard Stuff.
Oh, Sara: So lovely. So precious. And you are so much a MOM!
The C-section may not have been ideal, or wanted, or planned for, but you got the gift and joy and love at the end. As you say, not everything goes as planned and sometimes we step aside and let things be so that we can experience the joy intended.
I don’t appreciate the universe interfering with my plans AT ALL. But you’re right. It’s not like trying harder to control everything is going to work. Step aside….all will be well.
Every so often, I’m struck. By a loss for adequate words. But more intensely, by those emotions which cannot be described. This is one of those times. But, I must say: such beautiful and sweet memory keepers, aka photos. Much love to you All. Always.
I’m obsessive about photos because I know my brain can’t hold onto everything, but these visual reminders are enough of a trigger to keep me sharp.
When I look at your blog I can see someone who understands the desire to document it all.
Sometimes, there aren’t words.
Thanks you, Victoria.
It must be documented. These are the most important histories.
I didn’t want to keep showing up, like a bad penny, but I did want to say, “Staring Contest” really got me, and “Inuit Training” are my favourites.
Thank You, Sara.
There’s no such thing as a bad penny! Come in, come often.
Thank You, I’d love to. And I will.
Beautiful work, young lady.
Your child has been doubly blessed.
No matter how hard I am on myself for my faults as a parent, I feel calm about how great a dad she has. Some kids should be so lucky.
Thanks Hook.
Ah, that parenthood thing. Gets a person every time–for good or bad.
Well said.
Resistance is futile.
Beautiful. Wonderful. Amazing. Keep going. <3
YES MA’AM!
xo
That video made me tear up!
Disney ain’t got nothin’ on baby heartbeats.
Truer words have never been spoken.
Did you catch my 30th birthday pictures? I remember you wanted to see them.
NO! I will go. FB or WordPress? I’m the behind-est in everything.
WordPress. It’s my second to last post. Enjoy!
Ow, this is so joyously beautiful :-)
Those are kind and lovely words. Thank you.
My capacity to actually understand your feelings is limited (so limited in fact that some people may doubt I’m a “real woman” – f them, though), but I still want to say I’m glad it all turned out well for all of you.
What the hell is a “real woman”? People are dumb. You are real, you are a woman. What more is there?
Thanks, K.
I wonder about that every day! Ha.
Thank you.
Pingback: The Best Moment Award | Pondering Spawned
So beautiful, Sara. Just like you.
Flattery will get you nowhere….yes it will. xo
What could I possibly say that would justify the beauty of this one? :)
Nah, just please remind me to buy Poppy a new box of tissues for her fourth birthday (Seriously, that kid is the image of the clown! Just look at that face! And those eyes!). And please give that kid a good squishy hug from me. And a high-five to you and L’Eric as well!
Done and DONE!! Squishy hugs all around.
Absolutely cool. Very well written and completely unexpected in the different emotional turns this piece takes.
Loved this! Wish I had had the forethought to write my children letters on their birthdays during the early years. Your letter brought back so many of my own similar memories. Even though they are all in their 20′s now, you’ve given me a good idea for future birthday gifts!
Never too late! Your kids will love them, no doubt.